1582 Holly Pike, Carlisle, PA 17015
Absolutely FABULOUS! My mother recommended this place. My girlfriend and I have been there several times and will continue to go frequently. I’ve had eight different entrees’ so far. Every one delicious and portion sizes are quite filling. In addition, their prices are comparable and even better than most Carlisle area restaurants. Service is good and the atmosphere is warm and comfortable. The only recommendation that I could make would be to change their name to “The Carriage House Restaurant”. “TAVERN”, to me, suggests a “hole in the wall” dive bar. That’s exactly what I thought it was and had driven past many times on my way to eat at a “less than ideal” restaurant. I would and have recommended this eatery to many of my friends and have never heard anything negative.
If you like crab cakes you really need to try the Carriage House! I think they could be voted BEST in Carlisle!
If you want GREAT crab cakes, the Carriage House is the place to go. It was our first visit and we will be going back.
My husband had their Prime Rib and said it was good, we started off with the crab dip as an appetizer and it was wonderful.
I ordered the crab cakes, they are not huge but very little filler if any and big lumps of crab.
I got a greek salad and it came with the feta cheese and olives, another plus.
The only negative thing I can say is the side of red roasted potatoes was very small.
RC on Brad’s Pizza
Scott on Carriage House Tavern
Gregg sweigart on Bonanza Family Grill **CLOSED**
Fatima on Alfredo Pizza & Ristorante
Sri on Mt Fuji
Carlisle Restaurants WebAdmin on New Little John’s Family Restaurant *CLOSED*
Charles David on New Little John’s Family Restaurant *CLOSED*
Anne Goodwin on Spoons Cafe
Win a Gift Certificate to a Carlisle Restaurant!
Get Updates and Information on new restaurants, updates and other news!