Best Restaurants in Carlisle, PA

Posted: January 6, 2014 at 8:10 am   /   by   /   comments (2)

Instead of a Top Ten List like we’ve done in previous years (2013, 2012, 2011, 2010), we are going to split it up just a little and list the Top 3 from certain favorite Cuisines.

Three main categories showed up in our Top Rated Carlisle Restaurants list (which is always the current standing by visitors votes), plus one list of the best in a smaller niche.


  1. AYA Japanese Steakhouse
  2. Chen’s Asian
  3. Mt Fuji


  1. George’s Sub & Pizza Shop
  2. Alfredo’s Pizza & Ristorante
  3. Miseno Pizza & Ristorante


  1. North Hanover Grille
  2. Fay’s Country Kitchen
  3. Fairgrounds Diner

Worth it!

  1. Leo’s Ice Cream
  2. Courthouse Commons Espresso Bar
  3. Andalusia

Comments (2)

write a comment

Name E-mail Website

  • January 6, 2014 at 12:33 pm samiam

    What about the best sandwich award as his would cover many places.

    My choice, Vinney’s Italian

    I know what you mean by Worth It, but the category is still a little con using. What about, “If someone else’s paying”, or “It’s Your Birthday and someone else is paying”

    • January 6, 2014 at 2:54 pm Carlisle Restaurants WebAdmin

      @samiam – thanks again for your continued commenting on the site!

      Sandwich award – not a bad idea. I had someone that was eating quite a few hamburgers from the area and was going to put together his list of the best…. I should contact him again.

      For “Worth It”, I was adding restaurants that ranked well – but didn’t have enough ‘competition’ for the same cuisine type in Carlisle to put in a list against others…

      I like your suggestions and will see what I can do!